PEER REVIEW · October 2026

How to respond to reviewer comments

A calm, traceable approach to organizing reviewer feedback and preparing a clear response letter.

Reviewer feedback can be detailed, brief, or difficult to reconcile. A structured response helps editors and reviewers see what changed and where, while keeping the tone professional.

Build a response matrix

Create one row for every editor and reviewer comment. Include the comment, your planned action, the manuscript location, and the final response. This prevents smaller requests from being lost during revision.

Respond to each point

Quote or clearly identify the comment, then explain the action taken. Point to a section, page, or line in the revised manuscript. If you disagree, explain the reason respectfully and support it with evidence or a clear rationale.

Make the revision easy to verify

Use the journal’s requested method for marking changes. Check that the response letter matches the manuscript and that all referenced sections, figures, and supplementary files are present.

The authors remain responsible for the scientific response and all final changes. A careful, transparent reply is more useful than an adversarial one.